Skip to content
Paper 2 · Non-core Political Ideology

Feminism

Patriarchy is the central concept. Four strands of feminism share that diagnosis but differ on what causes patriarchy, where it lives, and how to end it. Built around the four strands and the Edexcel five named thinkers.

Feminism is the political ideology built around the claim that patriarchy - the systematic and institutionalised power of men over women - shapes society, the state, and the economy. All feminists agree patriarchy exists and that it harms women. They disagree about almost everything else. This walk-through opens with the sex-gender distinction that makes feminism possible, then takes you through the four strands in scrolly detail with their Edexcel named thinkers, then compares them across the four dimensions, and finally maps the strands onto the spec subsections the exam tests directly.

Part 1

Patriarchy and the sex-gender distinction

The foundation everything else builds on.

Patriarchy means the system of male power over women - in the state, in the economy, in society, and in private life. The word has been used by feminists since the late nineteenth century but the modern usage comes from Kate Millett's Sexual Politics (1969). All four strands of feminism accept patriarchy exists. They disagree about where it lives and what to do about it.

The conceptual move that makes feminism possible is the separation of sex from gender. Sex refers to biological differences between male and female bodies. Gender refers to the social roles that society attaches to those differences - how men and women are expected to dress, behave, work, parent, lead. Once you separate sex from gender, the social half is open to political change. Simone de Beauvoir's line in The Second Sex (1949) - "one is not born but rather becomes a woman" - is the foundational statement of feminism. If gender is taught, it can be untaught.

From this distinction follows another important phrase: the personal is political. If gender is socially made, then what happens in private life - in the family, the home, sexuality, marriage - is shaped by power and is therefore political. Kate Millett coined the phrase. All four strands accept some version of it; they argue about how far it goes.

One disagreement to keep in mind throughout. Are men and women essentially the same kind of human being (the androgyny position - "equality feminism") or are there real biological differences that should be valued not erased (the essentialism position - "difference feminism")? This argument runs through every strand and every dimension. The exam tests it directly.
Part 2

The four strands of feminism

Scroll - each strand lights with its Edexcel named thinkers and its position on the four dimensions.

The Edexcel spec recognises four strands of feminism. Each shares the diagnosis (patriarchy exists and harms women) but differs on where patriarchy lives and what to do about it. The five Edexcel named thinkers - Wollstonecraft, Gilman, Beauvoir, Millett, and hooks - are distributed across the strands. Rowbotham is treated as the canonical socialist feminist in most modern textbook treatments. Scroll through the strands; the figure beside you holds the four-strand summary card with the strand you are reading lit.

Step 1

Four strands, one shared diagnosis

Liberal, Socialist, Radical, Postmodern. All four agree patriarchy exists. They differ on cause, location, and remedy. Scroll through each strand in turn. The figure beside you holds the four-strand summary with the strand you are reading lit.

Step 2

Liberal feminism

The oldest strand. Focuses on legal and political equality and on reforming existing institutions.
Edexcel named thinkers: Mary Wollstonecraft (1759-1797) and Charlotte Perkins Gilman (1860-1935). Other thinkers: John Stuart Mill, Betty Friedan.

Liberal feminists argue patriarchy lives in formal legal and political exclusion - women historically denied the vote, the right to own property, access to education, and access to well-paid work. The remedy is reform: change the laws, fund childcare, enforce equal pay. Liberal feminism works within liberal democratic capitalism rather than seeking to overthrow it.

Human nature: Men and women are essentially the same rational beings. The apparent differences are products of socialisation, not biology (androgyny).
The state: The state is reformable. Pass anti-discrimination laws, fund childcare, enforce equal pay.
Society: Work on cultural attitudes and gender stereotypes through education and visibility.
The economy: Equal access to capitalism. Equal pay, equal opportunities, childcare provision so women can work on equal terms with men.

Critics (socialist, radical, postmodern) argue this leaves the deeper structures intact.

Step 3

Socialist feminism

Argues patriarchy and capitalism work together. You cannot remove one without removing the other.
Edexcel named thinkers: Sheila Rowbotham (1943-) is the main socialist feminist thinker. Charlotte Perkins Gilman (1860-1935) contributes the economic-dependence argument that socialist feminism builds on, though some of her ideas are also drawn on by radical feminism. Other thinkers: Friedrich Engels, Juliet Mitchell.

Socialist feminists argue patriarchy is not free-standing - it is propped up by capitalism. Women do unpaid domestic and care work at home; men sell their labour for wages. This gendered division of labour reproduces capitalism at no cost. In return capitalism keeps women economically dependent. The result: two systems of oppression that reinforce each other.

Human nature: Shaped by economic conditions. The gendered division of labour produces the apparent psychological differences between men and women.
The state: The capitalist state is patriarchal. Reform cannot solve it - only socialist transformation can produce real equality.
Society: Patriarchy works through the gendered division of labour. The personal is political because of capitalism (Rowbotham).
The economy: Capitalism cannot deliver feminism. Socialise reproduction (childcare, eldercare, domestic work) and abolish the wage-vs-unpaid-labour split.

Critics (radical) argue this subordinates women's liberation to class politics.

Step 4

Radical feminism

From the Latin radix meaning "root". Radical feminism wants to pull oppression up by the roots and start again. Not reform - replacement.
Edexcel named thinker: Kate Millett (1934-2017) is the main radical feminist thinker. Simone de Beauvoir (1908-1986) is a free-standing thinker whose ideas (especially the sex-gender distinction in The Second Sex 1949) are drawn on across feminism rather than being radical feminism specifically. Other radical thinkers: Shulamith Firestone, Andrea Dworkin, Catharine MacKinnon.

Radical feminists argue patriarchy is the oldest and deepest form of oppression - older than capitalism, older than class. The roots are in male control of women's sexuality, reproduction, and bodies. The personal is political - the family, marriage, sexuality and the home are not private but political. The phrase "the personal is political" comes from Millett's 1969 work. Radical feminism is the most uncompromising strand.

Human nature: Internal split. Most radical feminists are equality feminists (androgyny). Cultural feminists are difference feminists - real differences to be valued not erased.
The state: The state itself is patriarchal at its core. Reform cannot fix the deeper male power below the state.
Society: The personal is political. Family, marriage, sex and motherhood are political institutions structured by male power.
The economy: Economic equality is necessary but not enough. Patriarchy would continue under socialism because male sexual power is the deeper structure (Millett).

Critics (liberal, postmodern) argue radical feminism is essentialist and exclusionary.

Step 5

Postmodern feminism

Argues that "woman" is not a single category. Women's experiences differ by race, class, and sexuality - and earlier feminism missed this.
Edexcel named thinker: bell hooks (1952-2021). Other thinkers: Kimberle Crenshaw (intersectionality), Judith Butler.

Postmodern feminists argue that the earlier strands - especially radical feminism - spoke as if all women shared the same experience of patriarchy. They did not. The patriarchy a Black working-class woman lives is different from the patriarchy a white middle-class woman lives. The key concept is intersectionality - the way race, class, gender, and sexuality interact to shape each woman's specific experience of oppression.

Human nature: The categories of "man" and "woman" are partly made by society. Race, class, and sexuality shape the experience of being a woman as much as sex does.
The state: State-level solutions are too broad. The state treats all women alike but lived experience of patriarchy varies by race and class.
Society: Other strands focus too narrowly on the experience of white middle-class women. Intersectionality must be central (hooks).
The economy: The economic position of Black, working-class, and white middle-class women differs significantly. Attention must be paid to these intersections.

Critics argue postmodern feminism is too theoretical to mobilise politically.

Step 6

How the four compare in a sentence

Liberal: reform the existing system, equal access to capitalism. Socialist: patriarchy and capitalism together - need socialism. Radical: patriarchy is the deepest oppression - pull it up by the root. Postmodern: there is no single "woman" - patriarchy works differently by race and class.

All four agree patriarchy exists. They disagree on cause, location, and remedy. The exam expects you to know which strand says what on each of the four dimensions you have just seen.

Four strands of feminism with Edexcel named thinkers.
Liberal feminismReform
Wollstonecraft, Gilman
Human nature: androgyny - same rational beings.
State: reformable through legislation.
Society: change cultural attitudes through education.
Economy: equal access to capitalism.
Socialist feminismPatriarchy + capitalism
Rowbotham (main), Gilman
Human nature: shaped by economic conditions.
State: capitalist state is patriarchal; needs socialist transformation.
Society: gendered division of labour reproduces both systems.
Economy: socialise reproduction; abolish wage/unpaid split.
Radical feminismRoot (radix)
Millett (main); Beauvoir cross-cutting
Human nature: mostly androgyny; cultural feminism = difference.
State: state itself is patriarchal; cannot be fixed.
Society: personal is political - family, sex, marriage all political.
Economy: male sexual power is the deeper structure.
Postmodern feminismIntersectionality
hooks
Human nature: "woman" not a single category.
State: state-level solutions too broad for diverse experience.
Society: race + class + gender intersect.
Economy: different experience for Black + working-class women.
Part 3

The strands compared on each dimension

Scroll - each dimension lights one card per strand so you can read across.

Now the strands compared dimension by dimension. The exam tests one dimension at a time (Question 5a or 5b will ask about human nature, the state, society, or the economy - or about patriarchy, or about equality versus difference). The strongest answers hold all four strands' positions on that dimension clearly. Scroll through each dimension; the figure beside you shows the four strand cards with the dimension you are reading highlighted.

Step 1

Four dimensions, four strands

Human nature, the state, society, the economy. Scroll through each in turn - the figure beside you shows the four strands with the dimension you are reading highlighted.

Step 2

Human nature

Liberal: Men and women are essentially the same rational beings - apparent differences are products of socialisation (androgyny).
Socialist: Human nature is shaped by economic conditions; the gendered division of labour produces apparent psychological differences.
Radical: Most radical feminists are equality feminists (androgyny). Cultural feminists within radical feminism are difference feminists - real differences should be valued.
Postmodern: Race, class, and sexuality shape the experience of being a woman as much as sex does. "Woman" is not a single category (hooks).

Agreement: All believe gender roles imposed on women ignore their true nature (Beauvoir). Most are equality feminists - biological differences are insignificant. Disagreement: Difference feminists argue men and women are innately different and women should not seek to copy male behaviour.

Step 3

The state

Liberal: The state is reformable through anti-discrimination laws, suffrage, equal-pay legislation, childcare funding.
Socialist: The capitalist state is structurally patriarchal but socialist transformation can produce an emancipatory state.
Radical: The state itself is patriarchal at its core. Reform cannot fix the male sexual power that sits below the state.
Postmodern: State-level solutions are too broad. The state treats all women alike but lived experience varies by race and class.

Agreement: All feminists see the current state as not delivering equality and believe it must change. Disagreement: Liberal sees the state as reformable; socialist sees the capitalist state as patriarchal; radical sees the state itself as patriarchal; postmodern sees state-level solutions as too broad.

Step 4

Society

Liberal: Society is improvable through education, visibility, and breaking down gender stereotypes. Discrimination in the private sphere is historic.
Socialist: Society is structured by the gendered division of labour. The personal experiences of women are due to capitalism (Rowbotham).
Radical: The personal is political - family, marriage, motherhood and sex are sites of male power (Millett).
Postmodern: Other strands of feminism focus too narrowly on white middle-class women. Race, class, sexuality intersect with gender (hooks).

Agreement: Most feminists accept the personal is political and that the private sphere is shaped by power. Disagreement: What "political" means - capitalism (Rowbotham) or patriarchy (Millett); whose experience is the focus (white middle-class or intersectional).

Step 5

The economy

Liberal: Women need equal access to the economy - equal pay, equal opportunities, childcare provision (Gilman).
Socialist: Capitalism is at the heart of female oppression - socialise reproduction; abolish unpaid domestic work (Rowbotham, Gilman).
Radical: Economic equality is necessary but male sexual power is the deeper structure - patriarchy would continue under socialism (Millett).
Postmodern: Race and class shape economic experience too - radical and socialist feminism focus too narrowly (hooks).

Agreement: All agree the current economic system discriminates against women (Gilman, Rowbotham, Millett); domestic work is devalued and unpaid (Rowbotham); women have restricted access to well-paid work. Disagreement: Liberal vs socialist on whether capitalism can deliver feminism; radical on whether economic equality is enough; postmodern on race and class.

Step 6

How to use this in the exam

Pick the dimension your 24-mark question is about. Run through the four strands' positions in order. Identify what they agree on and what they disagree on. Reach a clear judgement on whether agreement or disagreement is greater. The textbook structure uses three paragraphs - typically two agreement paragraphs and one disagreement, or one agreement and two disagreement, depending on which way the judgement lands.

The four strands across the four dimensions.
Human natureSplits hardest
Liberal: androgyny - same rational beings.
Socialist: shaped by economic conditions.
Radical: mostly androgyny; cultural fem = essentialism.
Postmodern: "woman" not a single category.
The stateFriend or foe?
Liberal: reformable through legislation.
Socialist: capitalist state is patriarchal.
Radical: the state itself is patriarchal.
Postmodern: state-level solutions too broad.
SocietyPersonal is political
Liberal: change cultural attitudes.
Socialist: personal is political because of capitalism.
Radical: personal is political - family + sex + marriage.
Postmodern: race + class + sexuality intersect.
The economyEqual access?
Liberal: equal access to capitalism.
Socialist: capitalism IS the problem.
Radical: economic equality necessary but not enough.
Postmodern: race + class shape economic experience.
Part 4

The Edexcel spec subsections

Scroll - each Edexcel spec idea lights with its definition and how it sits across the strands.

Now you have the strands and dimensions in your head, here is exactly what the spec tells students to know. Five core ideas plus four key terms. Each 24-mark question (5a or 5b) is built off one of these. Scroll through them.

Step 1

Five core ideas plus four key terms

The five Edexcel spec ideas - sex and gender, patriarchy, the personal is political, equality vs difference, intersectionality - plus the four required key terms (public sphere, private sphere, essentialism, gender stereotypes). The figure beside you holds all nine cards with the spec idea you are reading lit. Scroll through.

Step 2

Sex and gender

Sex refers to biological differences between men and women. Gender refers to the social roles that society attaches to men and women. How important the difference between the two is depends on which strand you ask.

Strand positions: Liberal and socialist feminism treat gender as overwhelmingly social. Radical feminism splits - most radical feminists are equality feminists (androgyny); cultural feminists within radical feminism are difference feminists. Postmodern feminism argues the categories "man" and "woman" are themselves partly social.

Key thinker on this: Simone de Beauvoir - "one is not born but rather becomes a woman" (The Second Sex, 1949).

Step 3

Patriarchy

Society, the state, and the economy are shaped by systematic, institutionalised oppression of women by men. The shared diagnosis of all feminism.

Strand positions: Liberal feminists see only historic discrimination, not systemic patriarchy. Socialist feminists argue patriarchy is promoted by capitalism (Rowbotham). Radical feminists argue patriarchy is independent of capitalism and would continue under socialism (Millett). Postmodern feminists argue patriarchy mutates by class, race, and sexuality (hooks).

Step 4

The personal is political

Personal relationships, both inside and outside the home, are shaped by power and male dominance. Family, marriage, sexuality and motherhood are not private but political.

Strand positions: Radical feminists (Millett) treat this as the heart of feminism. Socialist feminists agree (Rowbotham) but argue the political content is capitalism not patriarchy. Liberal feminists are wary - the public sphere is the proper site of politics. Postmodern feminists agree the personal is political but argue the experience differs by race and class (hooks).

Step 5

Equality feminism and difference feminism

Equality feminists seek the same treatment for men and women on the basis that biological differences are insignificant (androgyny). Difference feminists argue men and women have a fundamentally different nature and women should not seek to copy male behaviour.

Strand positions: Most feminists - liberal, socialist, most radical, and postmodern - are equality feminists. Cultural feminism (a strand within radical feminism) is the main difference-feminist position; it argues society undervalues female-coded nature (childbirth, care, emotional work).

Step 6

Intersectionality

Black women and working-class women experience patriarchy in the state, society and the economy differently from white middle-class women.

Strand positions: The postmodern feminist position (hooks, building on Kimberle Crenshaw who coined the term in 1989). Other strands - especially radical feminism - are accused of focusing too narrowly on white middle-class women's experience.

Step 7

The four key terms

Public sphere - the world of work, politics, and the state; historically reserved for men. Private sphere - the home, family, and domestic life; historically reserved for women. Essentialism - the belief that men and women have inherent, biologically-rooted differences (the position of difference feminism). Gender stereotypes - fixed cultural expectations about how men and women should behave.

You must be able to define all four in the exam.

Five Edexcel spec ideas plus the four required key terms.
Sex and genderCore idea 1
Sex = biological. Gender = social roles.
Beauvoir 1949 on becoming a woman.
PatriarchyCore idea 2
Systematic male power over women.
Liberal disagrees; socialist + radical + postmodern agree on existence, differ on cause.
Personal is politicalCore idea 3
Family, sex, marriage = political not private.
Millett - the heart of radical feminism.
Equality vs differenceCore idea 4
Equality (androgyny) = most feminists.
Difference (cultural fem) = minority position.
IntersectionalityCore idea 5
Race + class + gender intersect.
hooks; Crenshaw 1989.
Public sphereKey term
Work, politics, state - historically male.
Private sphereKey term
Home, family, domestic - historically female.
EssentialismKey term
Inherent biological differences. Difference-feminist position.
Gender stereotypesKey term
Fixed cultural expectations about behaviour.
Part 5

The agreement-and-disagreement framework

Scroll - each spec subsection lights with its agreement and disagreement content, ready to lift into a 24-mark answer.

Every 24-mark question (paper 2 5a or 5b) asks you to evaluate agreement or disagreement on one spec subsection. The strongest answers hold both the agreement AND the disagreement clearly. Below the seven subsections are walked through one at a time - the figure shows all seven with the active one lit. Scroll the subsection your question is about and you have the three paragraphs.

Step 1

Seven subsections, two columns each

Human nature, patriarchy, society, economy, the state, equality vs difference, intersectionality. For each one: what feminists agree on (the sims) and what they disagree on (the diffs). Reach a clear judgement on which is greater for the subsection your question is about. Scroll through.

Step 2

Human nature

Agreement. All feminists believe gender roles imposed on women ignore women's true nature (Beauvoir). Most are equality feminists - liberal, socialist, most radical, and postmodern feminists agree biological differences between men and women are insignificant. They believe women's true nature should be allowed to evolve (Millett).

Disagreement. Difference feminists argue men and women are innately different. Cultural feminism (essentialist) holds that society undervalues female nature - childbirth, care, emotional work. Difference feminists argue women should not seek to copy male behaviour.

Step 3

Patriarchy

Agreement. Radical, socialist, and postmodern feminists all agree patriarchy is a pervasive system of oppression. They all argue women's oppression exists in both the public and private sphere. They all argue a radical overhaul of the system is needed.

Disagreement. Liberal feminists reject the radical definition - they see only historic discrimination, not systemic patriarchy. Postmodern feminists argue patriarchy mutates by class, ethnicity, religion (hooks). Socialists say patriarchy is promoted by capitalism (Rowbotham); radicals say it is independent and would continue under socialism (Millett).

Step 4

Society

Agreement. All strands agree women's personal experiences are shaped by their political situation (the personal is political - Millett). All agree on the importance of analysing the private sphere. Most agree on the androgynous nature of humanity.

Disagreement. Liberal feminists reject the radical view of patriarchy as a system. Socialist feminists argue the personal is political because of capitalism (Rowbotham); radicals because of patriarchy. Postmodern feminists argue minority and class experience is ignored by radical feminism (hooks).

Step 5

The economy

Agreement. All feminists agree the current economic system discriminates against women (Gilman, Rowbotham, Millett). All agree the work done at home, usually by women, is devalued and unpaid (Rowbotham). All agree women's access to well-paid work is restricted (Gilman).

Disagreement. Liberal feminists argue women need equal access within capitalism. Socialist feminists argue capitalism IS the problem. Radical feminists say economic equality is necessary but male sexual power is the deeper structure (Millett). Postmodern feminists argue race and class shape economic experience too (hooks).

Step 6

The state

Agreement. All feminists see the current state as not delivering equality. All agree the state must change.

Disagreement. Liberal: state reformable. Socialist: capitalist state patriarchal. Radical: state itself patriarchal - cannot be fixed (Millett). Postmodern: state-level solutions too broad to capture intersectional experience.

Step 7

Equality vs difference

Agreement. Most feminists - liberal, socialist, most radical, and postmodern - are equality feminists. They believe biological differences are insignificant and pursue gender equality on the basis of androgyny.

Disagreement. Difference feminists (including cultural feminists) argue men and women are innately different and women should embrace their female nature rather than copy male behaviour.

Step 8

Intersectionality

Agreement. All feminists recognise that patriarchy exists. Most contemporary feminists acknowledge that race and class shape women's experience to some degree.

Disagreement. Postmodern feminists (hooks) argue intersectionality is central - Black, working-class and lesbian women experience patriarchy differently and other strands have ignored this. Radical and socialist feminism is accused of focusing too narrowly on white middle-class women.

Step 9

How to use this in the exam

Read the question. Identify which subsection it asks about. Scroll to that step. Read the agreement and disagreement content. Write three paragraphs - typically two agreement paragraphs and one disagreement paragraph if the question leans "to what extent do feminists agree", or one agreement and two disagreement if the question leans "to what extent do they disagree". Reach a clear judgement.

Seven spec subsections - agreement and disagreement for each.
Human natureSims + diffs
Agree: gender roles ignore true nature; most are equality feminists.
Diff: difference feminists; cultural feminism.
PatriarchySims + diffs
Agree: radical, socialist, postmodern all see pervasive system.
Diff: liberal rejects; capitalism vs independent.
SocietySims + diffs
Agree: personal is political; analyse private sphere.
Diff: capitalism vs patriarchy as source.
The economySims + diffs
Agree: system discriminates; domestic work devalued; restricted access.
Diff: reform vs socialism vs deeper structure.
The stateSims + diffs
Agree: current state not delivering; must change.
Diff: reformable vs capitalist-patriarchal vs itself patriarchal.
Equality vs differenceSims + diffs
Agree: most are equality feminists - androgyny.
Diff: difference feminists - innate differences.
IntersectionalitySims + diffs
Agree: patriarchy exists; race + class matter to some degree.
Diff: postmodern centrality vs other strands' narrowness.
Part 6

Into the exam - essay plans and writing resources

Direct links to every feminism essay-writing resource on Panther.

The exam tests feminism through Paper 2 questions 5a and 5b - 24 marks each. Below are the predicted question packs, the strand-comparison exercise, the quiz, and the spec checklist already on Panther. Use them in this order: comparison exercise to test your strand knowledge, predicted-pack notes to scaffold an essay, paragraph completion to drill the structure, quiz to check recall.

Every feminism essay resource on Panther
Strand comparison exercise
Interactive tool covering all four strands across equality vs difference, plus the four dimensions (human nature, state, society, economy). Each prompt produces a model answer when you reveal it. Start here.
Predicted Q5a - Feminism and the state (full pack)
Pearson-style essay plan plus four drilling exercises. The notes page carries the structured essay plan (model answer); the paragraph-completion drills the textbook three-paragraph format.
Predicted Q5b - Feminism and human nature (full pack)
Same structure as the Q5a pack. The 2019 Q5a question on human nature is highly likely to return in some form.
General Q5 feminism pack
Broader feminism notes and recall quiz - not tied to a specific predicted question, useful when you do not yet know which dimension the exam will test.
Spec checklist + standalone quiz
Tick off every spec subsection as you cover it; the standalone quiz tests recall across the four strands and the named thinkers.
Past feminism Q5 questions - model approaches sit in the predicted packs above
The four past feminism Q5 questions you should know - their structured plans sit in the Q5a state pack (for state-related dimensions) and the Q5b human nature pack (for human-nature, society, patriarchy, economy dimensions). Each pack's notes page reads as a model answer plan.

Likely 24-mark questions to practise.

24To what extent do feminists agree over human nature? (2019 Q5a)

Approach: Para 1 agreement - all believe gender roles ignore true nature (Beauvoir); women emancipated when nature evolves (Millett). Para 2 agreement - majority are equality feminists; biological differences insignificant; androgynous nature of humanity (hooks, Gilman). Para 3 disagreement - difference feminists argue innate differences; cultural feminism as essentialist position. Judgement: agreement greater than disagreement.

24To what extent is feminism united in its views on society? (2023 Mock Q5b)

Approach: Para 1 personal-is-political (Millett); but postmodern feminists argue radical feminism ignored minority experience (hooks); socialist vs radical on what "political" means (Rowbotham). Para 2 patriarchy in society - radical, socialist, postmodern recognise; liberal does not; postmodern says patriarchy mutates by class/ethnicity (hooks). Para 3 equality feminism vs difference feminism. Judgement: lean disagreement.

24To what extent is there more agreement than disagreement within feminism on the economy? (2023 Q5a)

Approach: Para 1 agreement - current system discriminates (Gilman, Rowbotham, Millett); domestic work devalued (Rowbotham); restricted access to well-paid work (Gilman). Para 2 disagreement - liberal vs socialist on whether capitalism delivers feminism. Para 3 disagreement - postmodern adds race and class (hooks); radical sees economy as secondary to male sexual power (Millett). Judgement: roughly even; lean disagreement.

24To what extent do feminists disagree over their views on patriarchy? (2022 Q5b)

Approach: Para 1 agreement - radical, socialist, postmodern see patriarchy as pervasive; public AND private sphere; radical overhaul needed. Para 2 disagreement - liberal vs radical on what patriarchy is; reform vs radical change (Millett). Para 3 disagreement - postmodern critique of other strands (hooks); socialist vs radical on capitalism (Rowbotham vs Millett). Judgement: disagreement greater than agreement.

One worked essay

To what extent is there more agreement than disagreement within feminism on the economy? (2023 Q5a, 24 marks)
Line of argument: There is more disagreement than agreement. Feminists agree the current economic system discriminates against women, but they disagree fundamentally on the cause (capitalism vs male sexual power vs intersecting oppressions) and the remedy (reform within capitalism vs socialist transformation vs deeper structural change).
Paragraph One - Agreement within feminism
  • All feminists agree that the current economic system discriminates against women in different ways (Gilman, Rowbotham, Millett).
  • Feminists agree that the work done at home, usually by women, is devalued and unpaid (Rowbotham) - often called emotional or reproductive labour.
  • All feminists agree there are restrictions on women's access to well-paid work compared to men, and that the economy needs to be reorganised so women can access work in the same way as men (Gilman).
Paragraph Two - Disagreement within feminism (liberal vs socialist)
  • ×Liberal feminists argue women need equal access and opportunity within the existing economy. Socialist feminists disagree, arguing that the capitalist economy is at the heart of female oppression.
  • ×Liberal feminists pursue legal and political equality. Socialist feminists argue this is insufficient - economic equality requires socialist transformation, including socialising domestic and care work.
Paragraph Three - Disagreement within feminism (postmodern and radical)
  • ×Postmodern feminists disagree with both socialist and radical feminists, arguing that additional factors like race, class and religion also affect women's economic position (hooks). They argue radical feminism focuses too narrowly on white middle-class women.
  • ×Socialist feminists argue patriarchy is promoted by capitalism (Rowbotham), so abolishing capitalism is the route to feminism. Radical feminists (Millett) argue patriarchy is independent of capitalism and would continue under socialism, so economic transformation alone cannot deliver feminism.

Judgement. There is significant agreement on the diagnosis - all feminists agree the current economic system discriminates against women and that domestic work is undervalued. But the disagreement on cause and remedy is fundamental and goes to the heart of feminist political strategy. The strands have different answers to who women's economic oppression is FROM (men, capital, intersecting structures) and what to DO about it (equal access, socialism, deeper change). On balance there is more disagreement than agreement within feminism on the economy.

More practice on Panther

📊Strand comparison exerciseInteractive tool with model answers for every pair across every dimension. The single best practice tool for this topic. ✍️Paragraph completion - Q5a stateHalf-written paragraphs you complete - drills the agreement/disagreement structure. ✍️Paragraph completion - Q5b human natureSame drill format for the human nature question. 🧠Standalone MCQ quizTest recall across all four strands and the named thinkers.
Reference

Key terms - the Edexcel glossary

Open the glossary

Sex. Biological differences between male and female bodies.

Gender. The social roles, expectations and behaviours that society attaches to men and women.

Patriarchy. Society, the state, and the economy are characterised by systematic, institutionalised, and pervasive gender oppression of women by men.

The personal is political. All relationships - in society and in private life - between men and women are based on power and dominance. Associated with Kate Millett.

Equality feminism. Equality feminists seek equality for men and women on the basis that biological differences are insignificant. The position of liberal, socialist, most radical, and postmodern feminists.

Difference feminism. Difference feminists argue that men and women have a fundamentally different nature and that women should not seek to copy male behaviour. Associated with cultural feminism.

Intersectionality. The argument that Black women and working-class women experience patriarchy in the state, society and the economy differently from white middle-class women. Associated with bell hooks.

Public sphere. The world of work, politics and the state - historically the domain of men.

Private sphere. The home, family, and domestic life - historically the domain of women.

Essentialism. The belief that men and women have inherent, biologically-rooted differences. The position of difference feminism.

Gender stereotypes. Fixed cultural expectations about how men and women should behave.

Androgyny. The view that men and women are essentially the same kind of person, with the apparent differences being social rather than biological.

Radical. From the Latin radix meaning "root". Radical feminism wants to pull oppression up by its roots rather than reform existing structures.

Mary Wollstonecraft (1759-1797). Early liberal feminist. A Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792). Argued women appear less rational than men only because they have been denied education.

Charlotte Perkins Gilman (1860-1935). Liberal and economic feminist. Women and Economics (1898). Argued women's economic dependence is the foundation of their subordination.

Simone de Beauvoir (1908-1986). French existentialist feminist. The Second Sex (1949). "One is not born but rather becomes a woman" - the foundational statement of the sex-gender distinction.

Kate Millett (1934-2017). Radical feminist. Sexual Politics (1969). Argued patriarchy is the central political structure and the personal is political.

Sheila Rowbotham (1943-). Socialist feminist. Women, Resistance and Revolution (1972). Argued patriarchy is promoted by capitalism and women's oppression must be understood economically.

bell hooks (1952-2021). Postmodern and Black feminist. Ain't I a Woman? (1981). Argued mainstream feminism ignored the experiences of Black and working-class women - intersectionality.