Politics Panther · Paper 3 US Politics · Supreme Court and Civil Rights

SCOTUS and civil rights · Notes

Composition, functions, conventions, recent reform and exam-relevant past questions.
What this covers. The US Supreme Court is the highest federal court, established under Article III of the US Constitution. Nine justices, lifetime appointment, confirmed by Senate. Currently 6-3 conservative-liberal split (post-Barrett 2020). The Roberts Court has reshaped civil rights law since 2005, accelerating sharply since 2022.

Composition

9 justices: Chief Justice (Roberts) + 8 Associate Justices. Conservative bloc: Thomas, Alito, Roberts, Gorsuch, Kavanaugh, Barrett. Liberal bloc: Sotomayor, Kagan, Jackson. 6-3 conservative majority since Barrett's 2020 confirmation.

Appointment process

Presidential nomination - Senate Judiciary Committee hearings - full Senate vote (simple majority since 2017 nuclear option for SCOTUS). Recent: Barrett (Oct 2020 fast-tracked); Jackson (April 2022, first black woman justice).

Key recent decisions

Dobbs v Jackson (2022) - overturned Roe v Wade. Students for Fair Admissions (2023) - struck down race-conscious admissions. 303 Creative (2023) - free speech outweighs anti-discrimination. Trump v Anderson (2024) - states cannot disqualify Trump from primary ballots. Loper Bright (2024) - overturned Chevron deference. Louisiana v Callais (2026) - struck down congressional map and weakened Voting Rights Act Section 2.

Civil rights protections

1st Amendment (speech, religion, assembly). 4th Amendment (search and seizure). 5th Amendment (due process, self-incrimination). 14th Amendment (equal protection, incorporated rights against states). Voting Rights Act 1965 - Sections 4 and 5 weakened by Shelby County (2013); Section 2 weakened by Callais (2026).

Activism vs restraint debate

Activist court: Roberts Court has overturned major precedents (Roe, Chevron, VRA Section 2). Restraint argument: Court should defer to elected branches; lifetime appointments without democratic accountability problematic. Reform proposals: court-packing (expansion); 18-year staggered terms; ethics reforms post-Thomas / Alito disclosures.

Past 30-mark questions

P3U-2025-Q3C Evaluate the view that civil and constitutional rights have been successfully upheld. P3U-2024-Q3A Evaluate the view that the US Supreme Court is a political body rather than a judicial one. P3U-2023-Q3B Evaluate the view that the Supreme Court is now the most significant political actor. P3U-2019-Q3A Evaluate the view that the US Supreme Court protects individual rights more effectively than other branches.