Skip to content
Paper 2 · The Constitution · Devolution

Devolution, 1997 to 2024

Powers have flowed steadily from Westminster to the nations, punctuated by the 2014 referendum and post-Brexit strain. The exam question: has devolution strengthened or weakened the Union?

The arc at a glance

1997-98Created
2011Deepened
2012Deepened
2014Tested
2016Deepened
2017Deepened
2020Strained
2022-24Strained then restored

Click any step to jump to it - the lit step is the one showing below. A settlement that deepens almost continuously, then comes under strain. Green = strengthened or expanded · Amber = mixed or contested · Red = weakened or reversed.

The timeline

1 / 8

Timeline tucked away while you test yourself. Close the quiz to bring it back.

1997-98

What happened. Under Tony Blair, referendums in Scotland and Wales and the Good Friday Agreement in Northern Ireland led to the Scotland Act 1998, Government of Wales Act 1998 and Northern Ireland Act 1998, creating the three devolved bodies.

What it shows. Power is dispersed from Westminster for the first time - the start of asymmetric devolution. Created

2011

What happened. A Welsh referendum granted the Assembly primary law-making power (63% Yes).

What it shows. Wales moves from secondary to primary law-making - the settlement deepens. Deepened

2012

What happened. The Scotland Act 2012, following the Calman review, added borrowing powers and partial income-tax devolution.

What it shows. Incremental transfer of power continues. Deepened

2014

What happened. The Scottish independence referendum returned 55% No, 45% Yes.

What it shows. Devolution contained the independence pressure - the safety valve held at the Union's most stretched moment. Tested

2016

What happened. The Scotland Act 2016, delivering the Smith Commission promise of more powers, made Holyrood permanent in statute and devolved full income-tax rates and bands.

What it shows. The deepest transfer yet, fulfilling the post-referendum vow. Deepened

2017

What happened. The Wales Act 2017 moved Wales to the reserved-powers model.

What it shows. Wales catches up toward the Scottish model. Deepened

2020

What happened. The Internal Market Act 2020, passed without Scottish or Welsh consent, was seen as overriding devolved competences.

What it shows. Brexit recentralises some power and strains the settlement. Strained

2022-24

What happened. Stormont collapsed over the NI Protocol in 2022 and was restored in February 2024 with Michelle O'Neill as First Minister.

What it shows. Power-sharing is fragile but resilient - it broke and re-formed. Strained then restored

Roll up and down: use the arrows, scroll or swipe inside the box, the up and down keys, or click any step in the arc above.

The account: what changed?

The pattern since 1997 is deepening. The 1998 Acts created the three bodies; the Welsh 2011 referendum and the Scotland Acts of 2012 and 2016 transferred steadily more power, including tax. Devolution has become a permanent, asymmetric feature of the constitution.

The 2014 independence referendum is the pivot: a 55-45 No that contained the independence pressure and was answered with the Scotland Act 2016 making Holyrood permanent. The safety valve held.

Brexit then strained the settlement. The Internal Market Act 2020 overrode devolved objections, and Stormont collapsed in 2022 before being restored in 2024 - power-sharing proving fragile but resilient.

The judgement line: Devolution has deepened almost continuously and contained the independence pressure in 2014, but post-Brexit recentralisation and the fragility of Stormont show the settlement is tested as much as it is settled - the Union held, but not without strain.
Turn it into an essay: which dates argue which way

The same events split by side. Build each paragraph around one point from each column, then judge.

Devolution has strengthened the Union

  • 1997-98 Power dispersed by consent through referendums and the Good Friday Agreement.
  • 2014 The independence referendum returned a clear No - the safety valve held.
  • 2016 The Scotland Act made Holyrood permanent, answering the independence vote with more powers.

Devolution has weakened the Union

  • 2020 The Internal Market Act overrode devolved consent - a recentralising strain.
  • 2022-24 Stormont collapsed for two years - power-sharing proved fragile.
  • Asymmetry - uneven settlements fuel grievance and the case for independence persists.

The 2014 referendum cuts both ways: a No that strengthened the Union, but a 45% Yes that kept the independence question alive.

Quick check: ten questions
Question 1 / 10Score 0
Use it in the 30-marker

For "Evaluate the view that devolution has strengthened the Union", this timeline supplies both sides. The 1998 settlement, the 2014 No and the 2016 Act argue devolution stabilised the Union; the Internal Market Act and the Stormont collapse argue it has strained it. End each paragraph with an interim judgement.

Keep the dates precise: devolution Acts 1998, Welsh referendum 2011, Scotland Act 2012, independence referendum 2014, Scotland Act 2016, Wales Act 2017, Internal Market Act 2020, Stormont restored 2024.

Put the timeline to work on the judgement grid.
Open the devolution grid →