‹ All questions
Paper 1 · 2019 · 30 marks
Evaluate the view that the only political parties that matter in our political system are the Labour and Conservative parties.
Political Parties
Mark scheme: agreement
AO1: It remains the major parties who dominate Parliament and thus the government. AO2: Minor parties may cause a stir in by-elections, but they do not get enough support to control Westminster. AO3: We can conclude that as there is little chance of minor parties ever governing alone, therefore they matter less. AO1: The funding, wealth and organisation of these parties cannot be matched by other parties. AO2: The sheer size and scope of the funding system for the major parties means continued dominance for them. AO3: We can conclude that in the age of the media, PR firms and advisors money matters – the two main parties have this, the others do not. AO1: Other parties may have a few new ideas but the main cauldron of ideas rests with Labour & Conservative. AO2: Decisions and polices of importance like economic, foreign, law and order and welfare policy emanate from the two parties. AO3: We can conclude that the two main parties matter more when it comes to policy formation. AO1: FPTP will always favour the major parties and secure their dominance. AO2: Labour and Conservatives have established 'heartlands' where they usually win seats safely. AO3: We can conclude that the only thing that can damage these safe seats is electoral reform and neither party will acquiesce to this reform.
Mark scheme: disagreement
AO1: The continued dominance of the Labour and Conservative parties has declined. AO2: There has been a focus away from the mainstream with people joining other parties. AO3: We can conclude that small party membership is rising and recent elections show significant support for the Brexit Party and Lib Dems. AO1: The electoral and party landscape has changed with the emergence of other parties both in Westminster and in the regions and devolved areas. AO2: New electoral systems in the devolved regions have meant that votes for minor parties can now count. The SNP dominate Holyrood and PC have a strong base in Wales. AO3: We can conclude that additional electoral systems in the UK have made smaller parties matter more. AO1: Governing parties are having to call on other parties to prop them up in government as with the current DUP deal at Westminster. AO2: As FPTP has worked in the last 3 GEs a hung parliament is the most likely outcome at the polls giving power to other parties. AO3: We can conclude that support for the two main parties is not as solid is it once was and that smaller parties now matter more. AO1: Ideas from the minor parties shape the political agenda. AO2: The two parties have struggled to deal with many of the issues that smaller parties have raised SNP – independence, UKIP – Brexit, Greens -the environment. AO3: We can conclude that smaller parties matter more as the issues they raise have not been dealt with effectively by the two main parties.
Open in the full browser (plan, examples, save)
Saved